INGLEWOOD, Calif. — The Los Angeles Rams' preseason victory over the New Orleans Saints on August 22, 2026, at SoFi Stadium sparked a wave of optimism about quarterback Stetson Bennett. Headlines from major outlets declared Bennett ready to serve as Matthew Stafford's understudy, with some praising his "moxie" and strengthened backup case. But as the Vulius NFL Analysis Desk reviewed the game tape, a different narrative emerges—one that raises serious questions about the Rams' quarterback depth as the regular season approaches.
Box Score vs. Reality
Bennett's stat line was undeniably impressive, leading the Rams to a 17-0 first-half lead and finishing with multiple touchdowns. Yet, those numbers mask a concerning trend: Bennett consistently threw behind his receivers, missing several opportunities for big plays. On a critical slant route to rookie wideout Daniel Scott, Bennett's pass was late and behind, a throw that would be intercepted in a regular-season game against tighter coverage. This wasn't an isolated incident—it was a pattern that has persisted through two preseason outings.
As highlighted by film analysts on social media, Bennett can make the easy look hard and the hard look easy. His mobility provides a high floor, but his accuracy on intermediate and deep throws remains a liability. Against starting defenses, those missed windows will be punished. The Rams' coaching staff, led by Sean McVay, may be hoping Bennett's preseason performance translates, but the tape suggests otherwise.
The Backup Conundrum
While Bennett's struggles are notable, rookie Ty Simpson hasn't exactly seized the opportunity either. Simpson's second preseason appearance mirrored his first: flashes of athleticism undermined by inconsistent deep-ball accuracy. The same questions that plagued him in the opener remain unanswered as the Rams head into their preseason finale on Thursday. Neither quarterback has convincingly separated himself, leaving the Rams in a precarious position.
Could Los Angeles survive a game or two with either Bennett or Simpson under center? Possibly. But if Stafford were to miss an extended period—say, a month or more—the team's playoff hopes would likely hinge on a quarterback who has yet to prove he can handle NFL-caliber pressure. In a hyper-competitive NFC West, where every game counts, a single loss due to poor quarterback play could be the difference between a division title and a wild-card road trip.
Vulius Verdict: A Risk Not Worth Taking?
The Rams invested heavily in talent this offseason, adding playmakers across the roster. Yet, they may have overlooked the most critical position. As the Vulius Sports analysis team has noted, the backup quarterback market is thin, but the Rams' current options are a gamble. While Bennett's preseason numbers were flashy, the underlying issues are real. Simpson, despite his inexperience, might be the safer bet due to his higher ceiling and cleaner mechanics.
As the season opener approaches, the Rams must decide whether to roll the dice with their current backups or explore external options. The NFC West is loaded, and the margin for error is slim. If Stafford goes down, the Rams' Super Bowl aspirations could evaporate overnight. The Vulius NFL Analysis Desk will be watching closely as this story develops.
"The preseason can be a mirage. Bennett's stat line looks great, but the tape tells a different story. The Rams need a reliable backup, and right now, they don't have one." — Vulius Senior NFL Analyst
Looking to represent Stetson Bennett? Grab your Stetson Bennett jersey or design a personalized nfl jerseys at Vulius.
