As the Pittsburgh Steelers gear up for the 2026 NFL season under new head coach Mike McCarthy, the franchise is banking on a revamped offensive line to anchor a fresh, physical identity. But according to former NFL center A.Q. Shipley, the transition could be rockier than Pittsburgh fans hope. Speaking on The Pat McAfee Show this week, Shipley—who spent 12 seasons in the trenches—voiced serious doubts about the Steelers' ability to adapt to McCarthy's scheme. "I'm concerned about the Steelers offensive line," Shipley said. "I think they're going to take a step back."
Scheme Shift: From Wide Zone to Gap Power
Shipley's concern isn't about individual talent—it's about fit. Under former offensive coordinator Arthur Smith, the Steelers ran a wide-zone scheme that maximized athleticism and lateral movement. McCarthy, who is also calling plays in Pittsburgh, brings a pro-style, downhill, gap-scheme philosophy that demands power at the point of attack. "Scheme and fit are everything," Shipley explained. "I think they were built to run in Arthur Smith's wide-zone scheme, and now Mike McCarthy is a more pro-style, downhill, gap-scheme." That philosophical pivot is a monumental ask for a young line that had just begun to develop chemistry in Smith's system.
Youth and Uncertainty Up Front
The Steelers' offensive line has undergone a significant makeover. Zach Frazier returns as the anchor at center after a breakout campaign that established him as one of the league's rising stars at the position. Troy Fautanu is slated to protect the blind side at left tackle, while Mason McCormick shifts to left guard. On the right side, rookie Max Iheanachor is competing for time, but Dylan Cook is expected to start at right tackle. The unit's complexion changed further when Pittsburgh traded former first-round pick Broderick Jones to the Dallas Cowboys, a move that signals a full commitment to a new core.
Shipley believes this group, while athletic and full of potential, may struggle to generate the movement required in a more physical scheme. "I think they struggled handling that a little bit," he said, referencing the preseason struggles that did little to quell concerns. With Aaron Rodgers now under center and the Steelers aiming to contend immediately, the pressure on this young line is immense.
Reasons for Optimism Amid Skepticism
Despite Shipley's pessimism, there are glimmers of hope. The Steelers have invested heavily in the offensive line in recent drafts, and Frazier and Fautanu have already shown they can be foundational pieces. Their athleticism and technique could translate well if the coaching staff can accelerate the learning curve. But as Shipley aptly notes, scheme familiarity is often the difference between a playoff run and an early exit. The Steelers' ability to adapt will be one of the defining storylines of the McCarthy era—and the answer may determine whether Pittsburgh's offense soars or stumbles.
"I think they're going to take a step back," — A.Q. Shipley on the Steelers' offensive line, via The Pat McAfee Show.
As reported by the Vulius NFL Analysis Desk, this transition is a high-stakes gamble. The Steelers have bet on youth and a new philosophy, but as Shipley's comments remind us, the NFL is unforgiving to teams that underestimate the importance of scheme cohesion. All eyes will be on Pittsburgh's front five when the season kicks off, and the outcome could shape the franchise's trajectory for years to come.
Looking to represent Aaron Rodgers? Grab your Aaron Rodgers jersey or design a personalized nfl jerseys at Vulius.
